Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Zpycer's avatar

I agree with you about Heller’s brilliant Catch22, which I read at age 16 to present to my high school history class (that is a clear indication of how stupid our teachers were). This whole dog & pony show makes me think of that war and your letters, of Major Major Major Major. A little recap for your friend Baron Bethell if he is reading your letters, which I hope he is. Wiki is good for some things, so I’ll quote:

“Relating Catch-22 characters to William J. Goode's sociological definition of ineptitude, Jerry M. Lewis and Stanford W. Gregory describe Major Major Major Major as the ‘clearest portrayal of an inept role’ in the novel. They give three reasons for this: Maj. Major ‘always followed the rules, yet no-one liked him or trusted him’; his swift promotion to the rank of Major where he then remains is "a clear foreshadowing of the Peter Principle"; and the anathema to Maj. Major of being identified with Fonda, a symbol of competence, causes Maj. Major to retreat from everyone around him, making efforts to hide and to become, in the novel's words, a recluse in "the midst of a few foreign acres teeming with more than two hundred people". Lewis and Gregory state that Catch-22 supports a thesis that goes beyond Goode's, namely that the inept can identify their own ineptitude, and become active participants in its own institutionalization; whereas Goode asserts that the inept only ever have a passive role and can do little but accept their lot in life.”

Expand full comment

No posts